For generations, Lucibello’s Italian Pastry Shop has been a cherished part of New Haven’s culinary history. Known for its authentic Italian confections and unwavering commitment to tradition, this bakery has been a staple in the community since the Faggio family took the reins in 1959. From artisanal cookies to decadent cakes and perfectly crafted cannoli, Lucibello’s is more than a bakery—it’s a legacy of sweet memories.
A Taste of Tradition
The magic of Lucibello’s begins with its dedication to old-world European baking traditions. Every cookie is hand-cut, and every recipe remains untouched, preserving the authentic flavors that have made it a New Haven favorite.
“When you visit Lucibello’s, the smell alone might take you back to your first taste of a rainbow cookie or zeppoli,” the Faggio family shares. Whether you’re picking up a tray of assorted cookies for a celebration or indulging in a slice of their famous Italian Cream Cake, every bite tells a story of passion and excellence. 
A Family Legacy
The bakery’s roots stretch back to 1929, but it was Frank Faggio’s vision and dedication that transformed Lucibello’s into the institution it is today. Starting as a young apprentice at the original Chapel Street location, Frank eventually purchased the bakery in 1959 and moved it to its current spot at 935 Grand Avenue, where it continues to thrive.
Today, Frank’s son, Peter Faggio, carries on the family tradition, ensuring that every pastry, cake, and confection reflects the same quality and craftsmanship that made Lucibello’s a household name.
Award-Winning Sweetness
Named a Best New Haven Bakery Winner, Lucibello’s has become a destination for locals and visitors alike. Their menu includes Fine Italian Pastries, custom Wedding and Special Occasion Cakes, and arranged Cookie Trays that make every celebration special. It’s no wonder fans travel from near and far to enjoy these iconic treats.
“Holy Cannoli! It doesn’t get much better than those!” raves Robert K. from Connecticut. Lena R. from New York calls their Italian Cream Cake “a game changer.”
Make It a Memory
Lucibello’s isn’t just about dessert; it’s about creating moments. Whether you’re stopping in for a treat, reliving a fond memory, or placing your holiday orders (get them in early!), Lucibello’s invites you to be part of their story.
With nearly a century of excellence behind them, the Faggio family and Lucibello’s Pastry Shop continue to sweeten life for generations to come. Visit Lucibello’s Italian Pastry Shop on Grand Avenue to taste a piece of history and create a new favorite memory.
